Woke rating: definitions and scoring rules
Version 3. Use the same rules for every film so ratings can be compared.
Version 3 scores who a film puts on screen and how it portrays them, not only what it says. A cast mixed across ethnicity, sexuality and religion now counts (new category K). Gay, Black and other minority characters count only when they are either portrayed as flawless or given a different ethnicity, sexuality or religion from the original story's character (for example the 2025 Snow White), so a film that makes fun of gay people scores 0 on that point. White people, most often white men, cast as the antagonists or as the ones with bad values count under G. Showing a single gay or Black character is still not enough. A cast mix counts only where the story does not need it, and mixed couples are scored by how far apart the partners are in skin colour and culture. At its core, woke means lying for political reasons: presenting as true or ordinary something unlikely in the real world the film depicts, to promote a progressive view. See sections 1 to 3.
Version 2 keeps general left-leaning politics from being counted several times over: a political message without an identity angle (anti-war, anti-government, anti-corporate, class, environmental) is scored under J only. See section 3.
1. Working definition
"Woke" is a contested word. In this rubric it means:
Lying for political reasons: a film presents as true or ordinary something that would most likely not be so in the real world it depicts. The purpose of that is to promote a left-leaning, progressive view with a strong message of DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) that is being force-fed to its audience.
In practice a woke film tends to:
- have a cast mixed across ethnicities, sexualities and religions;
- portray gay, Black, African and other minority characters as flawless, or give an established character a different ethnicity, sexuality or religion from the original story (for example the 2025 Snow White);
- cast white people, most often white men, as the antagonists or as the characters with bad values;
- state progressive positions as a message.
Each of these counts as far as it bends reality to fit that view. A mix, a couple or a portrayal that the story or its real setting accounts for is not woke on that ground.
Simply showing a gay person or an African is not woke. A film that makes fun of gay people, or treats a minority character as a joke or an accessory, is the opposite of woke and scores 0 on that point.
The rating measures how prominent and intrusive all this is. It judges how the film portrays the world, not whether the political positions are right or wrong, and it is separate from the film's quality. A good film can score high and a bad one low.
2. Core tests
Ask these of every element before scoring it:
- One character or a mix? A single minority character in the background or a passing part, with no message, scores 0. A cast mixed across several ethnicities, sexualities and religions is scored under K.
- True to life or constructed? Something the story or its real setting accounts for (a true story, the people who would really be there, a plot that turns on it) counts less or not at all. Something presented as ordinary that would most likely not be so in the real world the film depicts, with nothing in the story to make it plausible, counts more.
- Flawless or flawed? A minority character or group counts only when the film portrays them as flawless (all virtue, no real faults, always in the right), or when the character's ethnicity, sexuality or religion has been changed from the original story (scored under E). One who is likeable but flawed, mocked, a caricature, an accessory or a villain scores 0. Mockery aimed at the groups or causes the messaging would celebrate counts towards the counterweight (section 5).
- Central or peripheral? A plot-driving theme or a lead character counts more than a passing joke or a bit part.
- Argued or shown? Speeches and on-the-nose dialogue count more than behaviour shown through story.
- One-sided? Opposing views that are strawmanned or absent count more than views given a fair hearing.
- Does it override the story? Plot or character logic bent to make a point counts more.
- Is it satirised? Messaging the film itself mocks counts less (see section 5).
3. Scoring categories
Score each category 0 to 3 using the anchors below.
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 0 | Absent, or presence only with no message |
| 1 | Brief or background (a joke, a line, one scene) |
| 2 | Recurring or plot-relevant, but not the film's main point |
| 3 | Central, repeated, or the dominant message |
Content categories (A to F and K, up to 21 points)
- A. Ethnicity. Black, African or other non-white characters portrayed as flawless, including as blameless victims of white people. Systemic racism, privilege, multiculturalism, DEI or identity politics as a message. Mixed couples shown, scored as set out under "Mixed couples" below. A non-white character who has real faults, is mocked, or is played as a stereotype or an accessory scores 0. A Latino or Hispanic character or partner does not by itself count as non-white, here or under K.
- B. Gender and feminism. Patriarchy critique, role reversals made to make a point, or women-as-victims or women-as-saviours framing.
- C. Sexuality and gender identity. Gay, lesbian, bisexual or trans characters with a real part, portrayed as flawless (all virtue, no real faults). LGBTQ+ themes, trans themes, or sexual-freedom advocacy as a message. A gay character played as a caricature or for laughs at their own expense, or a film that makes fun of gay people, scores 0.
- D. Power and systems. Critique of police, government, capitalism, corporations, colonialism or institutions, framed as oppression of an identity group (by ethnicity, sex, sexuality, gender identity or religion) or of a colonised people. Critique of war, government, business or the rich that is not tied to such a group is general politics and is scored under J only.
- E. Cultural and historical revision. Established characters, or real people in a true story, given a different sex, ethnicity, sexuality or religion from the original in a way that makes the cast more diverse (for example the 2025 Snow White), or history or source material rewritten to carry a message. What the original was like may be known from outside the film; the evidence is where the changed character appears.
- F. Religion portrayal (configurable). Islam shown as peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights (equality of the sexes, religious freedom, sexual freedom) in a way that works as a corrective message.
- K. Diverse cast. The main and supporting cast is mixed across ethnicity, sexuality (or gender identity) and religion in a way the story does not need. A mix that the plot turns on, that the true story the film retells had, or that the real time and place it is set in make likely is not scored (for example the cardinals of a worldwide church, an immigrant family, a multinational crew). Count only the rest of the mix, from characters with a real part who are shown neutrally or favourably: extras, characters there to be mocked, and villains do not add to it. 0: the cast is essentially one group, has a single minority character, or its mix is what the story or setting needs. 1: a few characters of another ethnicity, sexuality or religion in supporting parts. 2: the main or recurring cast is mixed across two of ethnicity, sexuality and religion. 3: the main cast is mixed across all three, or the film puts its mix on display.
Mixed couples (scored under A). A couple whose partners differ in skin colour, in culture (religion, values, the country and community they were raised in), or both, counts even without commentary, because the film chooses to present the match as ordinary. Score it in three steps:
- Prominence: 1 for a background or brief couple, 2 for a recurring or supporting one, 3 for the central romance.
- Add 1 (up to 3) when the partners differ in both skin colour and culture and the film shows the match as happy and untroubled, passing over a difference that would most likely strain it in real life. Example: a white American woman happily married to a Middle-Eastern Muslim man with traditional values.
- Take 1 off (down to 0) when the partners share a culture and differ only in skin colour, or when the story makes the difference part of the plot and deals with it. Take off 1 only, even if both apply.
A couple from a true story, shown as it really was, scores 0 here; what the film says about them is scored as usual. A Latino or Hispanic partner does not by itself make a couple mixed. Category A takes the highest score reached by its couples and its other elements.
Treatment factors (G to J, up to 12 points)
- G. Antagonist coding. White people, most often white men, are cast as the antagonists or as the characters with bad values (bigoted, cruel, corrupt or foolish), while minority or female characters are the good ones. Score how far the film's moral sides line up with ethnicity and sex: 1 for one or two such characters, 2 for a recurring pattern, 3 when the good and bad sides divide along ethnicity or sex throughout. It scores 0 when heroes and villains alike are mostly white men and no minority or female character stands out on the good side, or when the film makes fun of its minority lead as much as of those who oppose him. Villains coded only by ideology or class (conservative, patriotic, wealthy) are scored under J.
- H. Didacticism. Characters deliver speeches or lecture-style dialogue that state a message scored under A to F directly.
- I. Message over story. The story or characters visibly bend to serve a message scored under A to F, or the cast mix scored under K.
- J. Left-leaning politics framed as good. Political left-leaning messages are portrayed as good (fighting climate change, socialism, feminism, abortion-rights) and/or conservative values are portrayed as bad. This is the only category for general left-leaning politics: how prominent, preachy and one-sided it is all goes into this one score, and it does not add to D, G, H or I.
4. Calculation
- Add the scores for A to K (maximum 33).
- Rating = total ÷ 33 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5.
- Apply the counterweight in section 5.
- The rating cannot go below 0.
5. Counterweight
Subtract up to 1.0 point if the film mocks or complicates the messaging it contains, makes fun of the groups that messaging would celebrate, or gives opposing views a fair hearing. Examples: a gay lead played as a joke, satire of performative allyship or celebrity charity, flawed or hypocritical members of the group it sympathises with, or antagonists with real individual motives. Say what justifies the deduction.
6. Bands
| Rating | Label |
|---|---|
| 0 to 1 | None or negligible |
| 1.5 to 3 | Mild |
| 3.5 to 5 | Moderate |
| 5.5 to 7.5 | Strong |
| 8 to 10 | Pervasive |
7. Evidence rules
- Every point needs a timestamp and a paraphrase of what happens. Do not quote at length.
- Score only what was observed. If a part was not seen or heard (untranslated dialogue, scenes not seen), say so and lower the confidence.
- Report confidence as High (full video and audio), Medium (full dialogue, with parts of the picture not seen) or Low (summaries only).
- List elements that were considered but scored 0 because they were presence only.
- State which definition of F was used.
8. Limits
- The scale measures progressive messaging only. Conservative or other political messaging is noted but not scored here. A mirror scale can be added on request.
- Scores are judgements. The aim is consistency and transparency, not measurement.
Calibration: "Brüno" (2009)
Scored under version 3 (A to K, maximum 33). A prank comedy whose gay hero is a vain caricature, whose African baby is a fashion accessory, and which mocks celebrity charity as hard as the homophobes it provokes.
| Category | Score | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| A. Ethnicity | 0 | The African baby is a prop for jokes at Brüno's expense, not a flawless portrayal |
| C. Sexuality | 0 | The film makes fun of its gay hero; the gay gags are farce |
| G. Antagonists | 0 | The homophobes it draws out are not set against a sympathetic gay hero, since Brüno is the biggest joke |
| I. Message over story | 0 | Nothing under A to F or K for the story to bend towards |
| J. Left-leaning politics | 1 | Conservative views on homosexuality are laughed at |
| K. Diverse cast | 0 | Mostly white; the few others are props for jokes |
| B, D, E, F, H | 0 | None |
Total 1 of 33 gives 0.5. Counterweight of 1.0: the film mocks its gay hero, celebrity adoption and charity as hard as it mocks the homophobes. Final: 0 (None or negligible).
Calibration: "Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother" (2026)
Scored under version 1, before categories J and K were added, so this example uses A to I (maximum 27).
Confidence: Medium (full subtitles; some Arabic dialogue untranslated).
| Category | Score | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| A. Ethnicity | 1 | Jokes about ethnicity and stereotypes (22:23, 1:09:56) |
| B. Gender | 1 | Caregiving father, Khadija sermon (12:39, 1:00:57) |
| C. Sexuality | 0 | No LGBTQ content; porn is condemned |
| D. Systems | 1 | Distrust of the state (11:54, 31:00) |
| E. Revision | 0 | Original story |
| F. Religion | 2 | Mercy as the ideal, religious freedom tolerated, but sexual freedom absent and gender equality untested |
| G. Antagonists | 2 | Armed Christian militia is the main aggressor, with some individual motive |
| H. Didacticism | 1 | The sheikh's sermons (11:56, 1:00:57) |
| I. Message over story | 0 | Story leads |
Total 8 of 27 gives 3.0. Counterweight of 0.5 for satire of allyship (38:10), liberal tokenism (1:22:22) and flawed Muslim characters. Final: 2.5 (Mild).
Without category F (total 6 of 27 gives 2.2, minus 0.5): 1.5 (Mild).