WokeGauge
After the Hunt poster

Woke rating

After the Hunt

2025 · 139 min · United States, Italy · Directed by Luca Guadagnino · Drama · IMDb 5.7

Starring Julia Roberts, Ayo Edebiri, Andrew Garfield, Michael Stuhlbarg, Chloë Sevigny, Thaddea Graham

1.5/10

Mild

A Yale drama about a sexual-assault accusation that airs campus arguments about gender, ethnicity and pronouns at length, but treats its accuser, its activists and its feminist talking points as sceptically as the man in the dock.

Luca Guadagnino's drama follows Alma Imhoff (Julia Roberts), a Yale philosophy professor close to tenure. After a faculty party, her doctoral student Maggie (Ayo Edebiri) tells her that Alma's close friend and colleague Hank (Andrew Garfield) assaulted her. Hank says it is a lie told to cover up plagiarism, and Alma, who has a secret of her own, is caught between them.

The characters are academics who argue in theory, so the culture war is spoken aloud. A dinner guest complains that the straight white man is the new common enemy and is mocked for it. Alma tells Maggie that academia is run by white men who will never hire a woman who went public. Maggie frames her case as a young Black woman's experience in a white male institution, and Alma bristles at the pronouns of Maggie's non-binary partner. The later stages turn these arguments against Alma herself.

The characters are academics who argue in theory, so the culture war is spoken aloud. A dinner guest complains that the straight white man is the new common enemy and is mocked for it. Alma tells Maggie that academia is run by white men who will never hire a woman who went public. Maggie frames her case as a young Black woman's experience in a white male institution, and Alma bristles at the pronouns of Maggie's non-binary partner. Later, Maggie's newspaper interview accuses Alma of failing her as a woman and offering a Black student only tokenism, and Hank forces himself on Alma until she fights him off. Alma then confesses that the abuse she once reported as a girl never happened and that the man she accused killed himself.

What keeps the score mild is that the film puts nearly every position in a sceptical light. The accuser has a motive to lieMaggie is a plagiarist, a colleague mocks privileged students who nurse every slight, Alma tears into a student's objection to 'othering' and into trigger warnings, and Hank gets a full hearing. The film never settles what happened, and its plot turns come from characters' choices, not from a thesis.

Score breakdown

Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.

CategoryScoreWhat we saw
Content
A Ethnicity 2

Ethnicity recurs as a message: Maggie frames her case as a young Black woman's experience in a white male institution, and Alma warns that white men run academia. That recurring, plot-relevant talk keeps the score at 2. Maggie herself is not counted as a flawless portrayal: the film gives her a motive to lieshe turns out to be a plagiarist and her use of identity is shown as self-serving. Her relationship with Alex, who is white, is a supporting couple (2) of two young Americans in the same academic world who differ only in skin colour, so 1 comes off: 1. The film's wariness about how ethnicity is used is counted in the counterweight.

  • 1:00:25Alma's husband Frederik asks Maggie how often she makes doro wat; Alma later calls him an asshole for the way he treated her (1:01:32).
  • 1:03:33Alma warns Maggie that higher education is run by white men who will be afraid to hire her if she presses charges.
  • 1:14:55The Yale Daily quotes Maggie on being a Black woman in an elite, white, male-dominated field.
  • 1:16:30Maggie in bed with Alex, who is white; the couple appears again at 1:42:24 to 1:45:53.
  • 1:17:07Maggie tells Alex that when a young Black woman is assaulted, white people find a way to make it about themselves.
  • 2:02:21Maggie's interview says she is just another Black woman who hoped for recognition from a white woman and got tokenism.
  • + 1 point contains spoilers
B Gender and feminism 2

An assault accusation drives the plot, and feminist arguments about misogyny, consent and power are voiced repeatedly. Scored 2, not 3: the film tests these arguments rather than endorsing them, and leaves the case unresolved.

  • 0:13:21Alma answers a male colleague's complaint by listing what she achieved in a deeply misogynistic environment.
  • 0:28:35Maggie tells Alma that Hank kept going after she said no.
  • 1:04:54Maggie asks if she should keep silent just because women are penalised for speaking out.
  • 1:09:33Alma's friend Kim argues that a power differential makes consent all but impossible.
  • 1:54:37Hank tries to force himself on Alma until she shoves him off.
  • 2:01:53Maggie's interview calls their rift a feminist generation gap and says Alma subsumed herself to the patriarchal agenda.
  • + 2 points contain spoilers
C Sexuality and gender identity 1

Maggie is gay and her partner Alex is non-binary, but neither is held up as flawless: Maggie is a plagiarist, so their identities do not score as such. Scored 1 for the pronoun theme, which comes up twice, once with bystanders calling Alma's usage a slur; the film voices Alma's contempt as loudly as their outrage.

  • 0:15:52Alma tells Frederik that Maggie being gay does not mean she is in love with Alma.
  • 1:01:47Alma calls Alex 'she'; Maggie corrects her to 'they' and Alma repeats it mockingly.
  • 1:42:45Students who see Alma send Alex away ask whether she just used 'they' as a slur.
D Power and systems 1

Alma's warning that academia is a white male system that will shut Maggie out is the one critique of the institution framed around a group, and it is a single line. Yale's cowardice about optics (0:44:26, 1:39:57) is aimed at its fear of scandal, not at oppression of a group, and is not scored.

  • 1:03:33Alma's warning that white men who run academia will shut Maggie out.
E Cultural and historical revision 0

An original screenplay. No established characters, history or source material are recast.

F Religion portrayal 0

Islam is not portrayed. A guest lecture by a visiting scholar is shown only as an introduction.

K Diverse cast 0

The main cast is white apart from Maggie, whose being Black is part of the plot, since she frames her case around it, and whose relationship with Alex feeds the arguments about pronouns. The other non-white and gay characters are students and faculty in small parts, the mix a present-day Yale campus would really have, and the one student who gets a scene, Katie, is there to be taken apart by Alma (1:37:39). The mix is what the plot and setting account for.

Treatment
G Antagonist coding 0

The moral sides do not divide along ethnicity or sex. Hank, the accused white professor, has his own motives and gets a full hearing, but the women around him are no more admirable: Maggie lies about her work and Alma once invented an accusation. The student mocked for complaining about reverse discrimination is a single passing figure, and no minority or female character stands out on the good side.

H Didacticism 2

Progressive positions are stated outright in dinner-party debates and confrontations. They are in character for academics, and the counter-arguments get equally direct speeches.

  • 0:12:23A student says the straight white cis man is the new common enemy; Alma's long rebuttal follows (0:13:21).
  • 1:03:07Alma lectures Maggie on what going public will cost her as a woman in a white male field.
  • 1:09:31Kim's argument on power differentials and consent.
  • 1:17:07Maggie on white people making her assault about themselves.
I Message over story 0

The story leads. The film refuses to settle what happened, and its turns come from characters' choices (a forged prescription, a stolen document, a confession) rather than from a message or the cast.

J Left-leaning politics framed as good 1

A complaint about reverse discrimination is laughed out of the room, but the film is as sceptical of campus progressivism as of its critics.

  • 0:13:09The student argues that women now edge out equally qualified men; the others mock him and call him a moron (0:14:30).

How the number is reached

  1. Categories A to K add up to 9 of 33, which gives 2.5 (9 ÷ 33 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
  2. Counterweight −1.0: The film complicates every side: Hank says Maggie plagiarised her dissertation (0:39:04) and gets a full hearing (0:36:05), Kim mocks privileged students' possessiveness of their pain (1:10:03), Alma tears apart a student's objection to 'othering' and mocks trigger warnings (1:37:36), and a crowd of student activists is shown hounding Alma.Hank says Maggie plagiarised her dissertation (0:39:04), and Alma later confirms it (1:43:57); Hank gets a full hearing (0:36:05); Kim mocks privileged students' possessiveness of their pain (1:10:03); Alma tears apart a student's objection to 'othering' and mocks trigger warnings (1:37:36); student activists mob Alma until she collapses (1:59:38); and Alma's confession that she once invented an accusation that ended in a suicide (2:03:01) undercuts the case's framing, while Hank's assault on Alma (1:54:37) cuts the other way.
  3. Final rating 1.5, mild.

Considered, scored 0

  • Maggie as a character: the plot casts doubt on her account and her motives, so she is not a flawless portrayal (A, C).
  • Maggie's sexuality as such and her engagement to a woman in the epilogue (2:11:31), shown without comment.
  • A mixed Yale faculty and student body (1:40:30, 1:42:30), the mix the real setting would have (K).
  • The guest lecture by Hugo Micheron (0:50:44); Islam is not discussed.
  • A TV news report in the epilogueThe epilogue's TV news report that Meta is ending its diversity programmes (2:09:29), shown without comment.

Evidence and confidence

Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles (embedded track). A few stretches, such as 1:17:50 to 1:22:55, are wordless.

Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.

Noted, not scored: Several speeches push back on campus progressivism: Hank on the 'shallow cultural moment' (0:42:37), Kim on privileged students who nurse every slight (1:10:03), a joke about gender-neutral bathrooms (1:08:33), Alma on trigger warnings (1:38:33), and Alma's charge that Maggie chose her partner for their identity (1:45:11).

Rubric version 3. Reviewed 18 November 2026.