
Woke rating
Lucky Number Slevin
None or negligible
A twisty, wisecracking crime thriller with no progressive messaging; its central romance between a white hero and an Asian American heroine counts for a little, and its running jokes about a gay character offset that.
Paul McGuigan's crime thriller opens with a hitman, Mr. Goodkat (Bruce Willis), telling a stranger about a 'Kansas City shuffle', a con in which everyone looks one way while you go the other. It then follows Slevin (Josh Hartnett), a luckless young man staying in his friend Nick's New York apartment, who is taken for Nick by two rival crime lords living in towers across the street from each other: the Boss (Morgan Freeman), who wants Nick's debt paid by killing the Rabbi's son, and the Rabbi (Ben Kingsley), who wants his own money. Lindsey (Lucy Liu), the talkative coroner from across the hall, turns amateur detective and falls for him. The dialogue is quick and stylised, full of wordplay and old-movie references.
The only thing the rubric counts is that romance. Slevin is white and Lindsey Asian American, and theirs is the film's central love story, which the rubric scores on sight although ethnicity is never mentioned; both are Americans with nothing to set their upbringing apart, so it counts for less than it might. Everything else is presence. The Rabbi's son is gay, which the gangsters treat as a running joke and the plot uses as a way in; the crime lords are a Black man and a Jewish rabbi, defined by their feud and their crimes; and a detective's slur about 'darkies' and 'skullcaps' is a crude cop's talk, not a point the film makes.
The only thing the rubric counts is that romance. Slevin is white and Lindsey Asian American, and theirs is the film's central love story, which the rubric scores on sight although ethnicity is never mentioned; both are Americans with nothing to set their upbringing apart, so it counts for less than it might. Everything else is presence. The Rabbi's son is gay, which the gangsters treat as a running joke and Goodkat plans to exploit by staging the killing as a gay double suicide; the crime lords are a Black man and a Jewish rabbi, defined by their feud and their crimes; and a detective's slur about 'darkies' and 'skullcaps' is a crude cop's talk, not a point the film makes.
What keeps the score at the bottom of the scale is that nothing is argued. The plot runs on a revenge scheme decades in the makingfor the 1979 massacre of a gambler's family over a fixed horse race, the villains have personal motives, and no speech touches politics or identity. The jokes at the gay son's expense, never rebuked, offset the little the romance adds.
Score breakdown
Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 2 | Slevin, who is white, and Lindsey, who is Asian American, are the film's only romance, so as the central couple they start at 3. Both are Americans living across the hall from each other in New York, with nothing in the film to set their upbringing or values apart, so they differ only in skin colour and one point comes off, giving 2. Ethnicity itself is never a theme, Lindsey is a likeable, nosy neighbour rather than a model, and the Black crime lord is a villain; a detective's slur (0:52:28) is part of the counterweight.
|
| B Gender and feminism | 0 | Lindsey drives the amateur investigation (0:43:59) and is a coroner (0:53:56), shown as character, not framed through gender. The other women are minor: Max's wife and the girlfriend Slevin catches cheating (0:19:27). |
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 0 | Yitzhak, the Rabbi's son, is gay, and the plot turns on it, but he is a mark rather than a portrayal: the gangsters' routine about why he is called 'the fairy' (0:33:01) is played for laughs and the hitman means to use his sexuality as coverGoodkat plans to stage the killing as a gay double suicide (0:50:31). No gay character is portrayed as flawless, and the jokes count towards the counterweight. |
| D Power and systems | 0 | Corrupt police are crime-genre texture: Slevin says the gangsters buy cops like cops buy donuts (0:55:31), and the detective once signed his paycheques over to the Rabbi (0:54:22). No institution is framed as oppressing a group. |
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | An original screenplay; nothing established is recast or revised. |
| F Religion portrayal | 0 | Islam does not feature. Religion appears only as the irony of a rabbi who is a gangster (0:40:35), who cites the Jewish rule against premeditated murder (0:42:13). |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | The characters with a real part who are shown neutrally or favourably are Slevin, Lindsey and Goodkat. The Boss and the Rabbi, with their Black and Hasidic crews, are villains, and Yitzhak, the gay son, is a mark and the butt of jokes, so none of them adds to the mix. That leaves Lindsey as the one minority character with a real part. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | The villains are rival crime lords, a Black man and a Jewish rabbi, their hired men and a corrupt white detective, defined by their feud and their crimes, chiefly the 1979 massacre (1:35:10), with personal motives such as the Boss's murdered son (0:31:51). The hero is a white man, and the moral sides do not divide along ethnicity or sex. |
| H Didacticism | 0 | The speeches are about luck (0:39:56), revenge (0:32:21) and old films, and none carries a social message. |
| I Message over story | 0 | A puzzle-box revenge plot whose turns serve the twist; none bends toward a message. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 0 | No politics appear, left or right. |
How the number is reached
- Categories A to K add up to 2 of 33, which gives 0.5 (2 ÷ 33 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
- Counterweight −0.5: The film makes fun of its one gay character: the gangsters' routine about why Yitzhak is called 'the fairy', with wings and magic dust (0:33:01 to 0:33:33), Slevin's own use of the nickname (0:57:21) and the hitman's cover storyGoodkat's plan to pass the killing off as a gay double suicide (0:50:31) are played for laughs and never rebuked, and a detective's slur about 'darkies' and 'skullcaps' (0:52:28) passes without comment.
- Final rating 0.0, none or negligible.
Considered, scored 0
- Yitzhak as a gay character (0:33:19), whose father 'doesn't know' though everybody does (0:33:28), and whom Slevin asks on a date (0:59:37): a mark and a joke, not a flawless portrayal (C).
- The Boss, a Black crime lord, and the Rabbi, a Jewish one, as the two rival gangsters, with a Black gangland crew and Hasidic heavies (0:29:30, 0:37:30): villains, so they count neither under A nor towards a mixed cast (K).
- Lindsey, an Asian American coroner (0:53:56), the one minority character with a real part on the good side (K).
- Ex-Mossad bodyguards guarding Yitzhak (0:49:17), a plot obstacle.
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. The file has no English text subtitles, so the dialogue comes from a transcript of the English audio. It covers the whole film but garbles names (Slevin often comes out as 'Levin', Kelevra as 'Galevra', Goodkat as 'Good Cat', Yitzhak as 'Itzhak' or 'Hisoc', Brikowski as 'Borkowski' or 'Dombroski'), runs some fast exchanges together and mangles the closing song. Two stretches have little dialogue: the shoot-out at Yitzhak's apartment (about 1:10:45 to 1:13:50) and the end of the reveal (about 1:39:00 to 1:41:20).
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Rubric version 3. Reviewed 18 November 2026.