
Woke rating
Supergirl
None or negligible
A space revenge adventure that sets a hard-drinking, far from flawless Supergirl and a vengeful girl against an all-male band of raiders who hunt girls as brides; it makes no speeches and carries no other messaging.
Craig Gillespie's adaptation of Tom King's comic Woman of Tomorrow follows Kara Zor-El (Milly Alcock), Superman's younger cousin, who spends her birthday drinking under red suns where she has no powers. Ruthye (Eve Ridley), a girl whose family was murdered by the raider Krem (Matthias Schoenaerts), asks her for help, and when Krem shoots Kara's dog Krypto with a slow poison the two set off across the galaxy after him, Kara for the antidote and Ruthye for revenge.
The only messaging is in how the sides are drawn. Krem's Brigands are an all-male race who scavenge planets for girls to carry on their line, so the heroes, a young woman and a girl, are up against men who take girls, and that thread runs through the chase. Nobody draws a lesson about men and women from it, though, and the film's real subject is grief and revenge: Kara, who saw the last of Krypton die, spends the film trying to talk Ruthye out of killing.
The only messaging is in how the sides are drawn. Krem's Brigands are an all-male race who scavenge planets for girls to carry on their line, so the heroes, a young woman and a girl, are up against men who take girls: a couple on Bilquis trade Kara and Ruthye for their own abducted daughter, and the climax has Kara freeing the Brigands' captive brides. Nobody draws a lesson about men and women from it, though, and the film's real subject is grief and revenge: Kara, who saw the last of Krypton die, talks Ruthye out of killing Krem in the end.
It scores almost nothing. Kara is no flawless heroine: she drinks so as not to feel anything, admits she is rude and breaks a man's arm in a bar fight, and Ruthye tells her she does not want to be like her. Women do wrong too, from the female space pirates who rob the bus to a couple who betray the heroesMareck, who poisons Kara, while Superman, Kara's father and an outlaw bounty hunterLobo stand on the good side. Ruthye, played by an actress of East Asian appearance, is the only non-white character with a real part shown favourably, nobody's sexuality or religion comes up, and no one lectures on any social issue.
Score breakdown
Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 0 | Ethnicity never comes up. Ruthye is played by an actress of East Asian appearance and Bomar, one of the couple who take the heroes in on Bilquis, by a Black actor, but neither is held up as flawless: Ruthye is headstrong and bent on killing, and the couple have their own agenda, and the couple drug Kara to sell her and Ruthye to the Brigands. Ruthye's parents are a brief couple who differ in appearance but come from one clan on one planet, so 1 less 1 gives 0. |
| B Gender and feminism | 1 | The villains' crime is gendered: the Brigands are an all-male race who scavenge planets for girls to carry on their line, so a young woman and a girl are up against men who take girls, and the climax ends with Kara freeing their captive brides. Scored 1, not 2: it is genre villainy, shown and never argued, nobody makes a point about men and women, and women are on the bad side too.
|
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 0 | No gay, lesbian, bisexual or trans character or theme. |
| D Power and systems | 0 | No institution is framed as oppressing a group. The Brigands are a raider band, and Krypton's council that ignored the warnings (0:42:05) is Superman lore. |
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | Adapted from Tom King and Bilquis Evely's comic Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, keeping its core of Kara, Ruthye, Krem and Krypto. Kara, Superman and her parents are cast close to the comics, Lobo keeps the comics' chalk-white look (1:25:30), and no actor is cast across sex. Ruthye, an alien girl in the comic, is played by an actress of East Asian appearance; the comic does not tie her people to any Earth ethnicity, so it is not scored as a change. |
| F Religion portrayal | 0 | Islam does not appear. |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | The characters with a real part are mostly white: Kara, Superman, Kara's parents, Krem and his lieutenant Drom Baxton, and Lobo, made up as the comics' chalk-skinned alien. Ruthye is the one non-white character with a real part who is shown favourably; her mother appears only in the opening minutes, and the other non-white characters with real parts, the couple on Bilquis and one of the space pirates, act against the heroesMareck and Bomar, who sell the heroes out, and one of the space pirates, are on the wrong side. Nobody's sexuality or religion comes up, and no actor is cast across sex. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 1 | The main villain, Krem, is played by a white man and leads an all-male band of raiders, while the heroes are a young woman and a girl. Scored 1, not more: the sides do not divide by sex or ethnicity throughout. Superman and Kara's father are good men, an outlaw bounty hunter turns allyLobo helps bring down the Brigands (1:19:05), and women and non-white characters do wrong too: three female space pirates, one of them Black, rob the bus (0:22:13, 0:31:30), and a couple the heroes trust have their own agenda, and Mareck and Bomar poison Kara to trade her for their daughter (0:53:18).
|
| H Didacticism | 0 | No speech states a social or political message. Kara's talks with Ruthye about grief and revenge (0:49:54, 1:33:43) carry the film's theme, which is not scored under A to F. |
| I Message over story | 0 | The revenge chase leads throughout; nothing bends towards a message. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 0 | No political camp is framed as good or bad. Krypton's council ignoring Zor-El's and Jor-El's warnings (0:42:05) is long-standing Superman lore, and the atomic wars that ruined Bilquis (0:31:16) are backdrop. |
How the number is reached
- Categories A to K add up to 2 of 33, which gives 0.5 (2 ÷ 33 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
- Counterweight −0.5: The film complicates its gendered sides: Kara is flawed, drinking so as not to feel (0:06:36, 0:29:44), admitting she is rude (0:40:50) and breaking a man's arm in a bar fight (0:36:42), and Ruthye says she does not want to be like her (1:02:57); female space pirates rob the bus (0:23:52), and Superman and Kara's father are on the good side (0:13:17, 0:42:05).The film complicates its gendered sides: Kara is flawed, drinking so as not to feel (0:06:36, 0:29:44), admitting she is rude (0:40:50) and breaking a man's arm in a bar fight (0:36:42), and Ruthye says she does not want to be like her (1:02:57); female space pirates rob the bus (0:23:52), Mareck poisons Kara to buy back her daughter (0:52:20, 0:53:18), and Superman, Kara's father and Lobo are on the good side (0:13:17, 0:42:05, 1:19:05).
- Final rating 0.0, none or negligible.
Considered, scored 0
- Ruthye, played by an actress of East Asian appearance (0:08:30): an alien girl from the comic, headstrong and vengeful rather than flawless (A, E), and the one non-white character with a real part shown favourably (K).
- Ruthye's parents, Elias and Delilah Knoll (0:03:30), a white man and a woman of East Asian appearance: a brief couple of one clan and planet who differ only in appearance, so 1 less 1 gives 0 (A).
- Bomar and Mareck (0:38:30, 0:51:30), a non-white couple on Bilquis who take the heroes in and then poison Kara to trade her and Ruthye for their abducted daughter (0:53:18): not a mixed couple and not flawless (A, K).
- The three female space pirates who rob the bus, one of them played by a Black actress (0:31:30): villains, so they add nothing (K).
- Lobo, played by Jason Momoa in the comics' chalk-white look (0:37:36, 1:25:30): not a change of ethnicity (E).
- Ruthye's cut-off question why Superman is a man and Kara a girl (0:33:23): a joke about the names, with no point about women (B).
- Kara as the survivor of a dead world who tells Clark she has no people on Earth (0:13:41): the Superman family's long-standing story of finding a home, with no political point.
- No same-sex or trans characters appear.
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles. The Kryptonian dialogue, mostly in the flashback to Argo City (0:42:00 to 0:49:00), is not in the subtitle track and was only partly available in translation, some alien dialogue is left untranslated, and one line of Kara's at the climax (1:34:17) is inaudible.
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Rubric version 3. Reviewed 20 November 2026.