WokeGauge
Totally Killer poster

Woke rating

Totally Killer

2023 · 104 min · United States · Directed by Nahnatchka Khan · Horror, Comedy, Science Fiction · IMDb 6.5

Starring Kiernan Shipka, Olivia Holt, Troy Leigh-Anne Johnson, Lochlyn Munro, Charlie Gillespie, Kelcey Mawema

1.5/10

Mild

A time-travel slasher comedy whose Gen Z heroine keeps tutting at 1980s sexism, fat jokes and homophobia, though the film laughs at her corrections as often as it backs them.

Nahnatchka Khan's horror comedy follows Jamie (Kiernan Shipka), a 17-year-old whose mother is murdered on Halloween by the masked Sweet 16 Killer, who first struck in 1987. Fleeing the killer, Jamie stumbles into her best friend's science-fair time machine, lands in 1987, poses as an exchange student from Canada and tries to stop the original murders with the help of her teenage mother's circle and a young inventor. It is a slasher whodunit crossed with Back to the Future.

The messaging comes through the culture-clash comedy. Jamie meets gym shorts she likens to a Hooters uniform, a coach who runs dodgeball like a war, a jock who says women should not drive and girls who call a dead classmate 'Fat Trish', and she answers with modern one-liners: unwanted touch, women should lift each other up, gay people are amazing. A brief remark about racism and an aside about men showing emotion complete the pattern, and two mixed couples appear without comment. The 1987 town is also cast with more ethnic variety than a small American town of the time would likely have had. None of it becomes a speech, and none of it drives the plot, which runs on grief and revenge.

The messaging comes through the culture-clash comedy. Jamie meets gym shorts she likens to a Hooters uniform, a coach who runs dodgeball like a war, a jock who says women should not drive and girls who call a dead classmate 'Fat Trish', and she answers with modern one-liners: unwanted touch, women should lift each other up, gay people are amazing. A brief remark about racism and an aside about men showing emotion complete the pattern, and two mixed couples appear without comment, Marisa and Randy, and Doug and Trish. The 1987 town is also cast with more ethnic variety than a small American town of the time would likely have had. None of it becomes a speech, and none of it drives the plot, which turns on Trish's death after a night of bullying and on a podcaster's hunger for fame.

What keeps the score low is that the film makes Jamie's corrections part of the joke. Her plea for female solidarity is answered with a flash and a laugh, her rush to say gay people are amazing comes right after she blurts out 'Gross!', and her tree-planting petition is a trick the popular girls mock. The 1980s teenagers are crude but given sympathy, and the villain has a personal motive rather than a demographic labelturns out to be two men with personal motives: Doug, avenging his girlfriend, and Chris Dubasage, who wants fame and resents his father.

Score breakdown

Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.

CategoryScoreWhat we saw
Content
A Ethnicity 1

Brief touches only: a throwaway line about 1980s racism, and two mixed couples shown without comment. A couple from the past whose story matters to the plotDoug, who is Black, and Trish, who was white, whose romance turns out to be the original killer's motive gets 2 for prominence, less 1 because the two are teenagers from the same small town who share a culture and differ only in skin colour. A brief hook-up between Randy, who is Black, and Marisa, who is Asian-American, goes from 1 to 0 for the same reason. No non-white character is held up as flawless: Randy is a crude jock, Marisa a mean girl and Sheriff Lim a figure of fun.

  • 0:23:13On her first morning in 1987 Vernon, Jamie groans that here is the racism, she knew it was coming.
  • 1:27:25Doug, who is Black, carries a locket with a photo of Trish, a white girl; the Mollys explain the two were boyfriend and girlfriend (1:27:32).
  • + 1 point contains spoilers
B Gender and feminism 2

The clash between 1980s sexism and Jamie's modern manners is a running joke from gym class to the finale, but it is played for laughs, often at Jamie's expense, and is never the film's point.

  • 0:24:14Jamie says the girls' school-issued gym kit makes them look like Hooters waitresses; the coach then runs dodgeball as a brutal free-for-all (also 0:25:30).
  • 0:35:18Jamie protests 'unwanted touch' when a jock shoves her away from the party door; he answers 'unwanted human'.
  • 0:38:19Jamie tells the Mollys their mean-girl act is outdated and women should lift each other up; Pam answers by flashing her, to laughter.
  • 0:56:07Randy says a girl's fatal drunk-driving crash shows women should not drive; Jamie corrects him that people should not drive drunk, and Blake retorts that that is just what a girl would say (0:56:18).
  • 1:14:34As the teen rock singer talks about grief on TV, a dry aside marvels at men showing emotion.
  • 1:18:45A boy muses that Tiffany might be alive if she had agreed to oral sex; Jamie says that should not be the lesson.
C Sexuality and gender identity 1

One scene, played as a joke on Jamie's overcorrection; the phrase then recurs as a gag.

  • 1:01:30Asked whether she wanted to 'lez out' for the weekend, Jamie blurts 'Gross!', then scrambles to say she meant the comment, not gay people, who are amazing, and that it had homophobic undertones (1:01:36). The phrase returns as a gag (1:02:15, 1:07:49).
D Power and systems 0

The 1987 sheriff waves off Jamie's warnings and laughs at the idea of DNA, but as period comedy about small-town policing, not a critique of police as oppressors of a group.

E Cultural and historical revision 0

An original story that riffs openly on Back to the Future and 1980s slashers. No established characters or history are recast.

F Religion portrayal 0

Islam does not feature, and religion plays no part in the story.

K Diverse cast 1

The 1987 town is cast with a mix across ethnicity that nothing in the story calls for and that a small American town of the time would not likely have had: Lauren, the gifted Black student who helps Jamie, and her daughter Amelia in the present, the Black jock Randy, the Asian-American Molly, Marisa, and Sheriff Lim and his daughter Kara, alongside a white lead circle. Scored 1, not more: the mix is of ethnicity only and in supporting parts; Lim is a figure of fun and Doug a villain, so neither adds to it.

  • 0:30:02Jamie finds Lauren Creston in class and enlists her to rebuild the time machine; her daughter Amelia built it in the present (0:30:27).
  • 0:34:41Randy, a Black jock, and Kara Lim mock Doug at the party (0:35:07).
  • 0:24:30Marisa, an Asian-American Molly, stands with the popular girls in gym class (also 0:26:48).
  • 1:12:24Sheriff Lim, who is Asian-American, laughs off Jamie's talk of DNA with his deputy (also 1:12:30).
Treatment
G Antagonist coding 0

The killer iskillers are defined by personal grievance, not by demographic or ideology: Doug, who is Black, avenges his girlfriend Trish, who died after a night of the Mollys' bullying, and Chris, who is white, kills for podcast fame and out of resentment of his father. The crude and sexist 1980s teenagers are boys and girls of several backgrounds, Randy among them, so the sides do not divide along ethnicity or sex.

H Didacticism 1

No speeches. The message comes in short, on-the-nose one-liners, mostly Jamie's, and each is undercut by the scene around it.

  • 0:38:21Women should be lifting each other up.
  • 0:55:56Jamie tells the Mollys they cannot call a dead classmate 'Fat Trish'; they reply that they no longer do, since she is dead.
  • 1:01:36Gay people are amazing; the comment had homophobic undertones.
I Message over story 0

The plot is a whodunit and a time-travel puzzle, and none of its turns bends toward a message.

J Left-leaning politics framed as good 1

In the background, today's manners are the yardstick the 1980s fail. Environmentalism appears only as two jokes, one admiring and one mocked; no politics are argued and nothing conservative is put down.

  • 0:03:13Jamie defends a rock singer her mother disliked: he now runs a clean-water charity, and his middle finger is aimed at single-use plastic.
  • 0:57:23Jamie's petition to plant a tree for Tiffany and give back to the environment is a ruse to compare handwriting; the Mollys laugh it off (also 1:04:36).

How the number is reached

  1. Categories A to K add up to 7 of 33, which gives 2.0 (7 ÷ 33 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
  2. Counterweight −0.5: The film makes Jamie's corrections part of the joke: her call for female solidarity is answered with a flash and a laugh (0:38:25), her 'gay people are amazing' follows her own blurted 'Gross!' (1:01:35), and her environmental petition is a trick the others mock (0:57:40). The 1980s teens are crude but treated with sympathy (0:46:30), and the killer has a personal motivethe killers have personal motives: Doug's grief for Trish (1:27:28) and Chris's craving for fame (1:33:56).
  3. Final rating 1.5, mild.

Considered, scored 0

  • Randy and Marisa's hook-up at the cabin (1:09:06): two teenagers from the same town who differ only in skin colour, so it drops to 0 (A).
  • Lauren and Amelia Creston as gifted inventors who build the time machine: likeable helpers whose talent is shown, not argued, and who have no story of their own to make them models (A); they are counted in the cast mix under K.
  • The 1987 sheriff's scoffing at Jamie's warning and at DNA (0:28:11, 1:12:27), played as period comedy.
  • Frank teen talk about sex, alcohol and weed, part of the 1980s teen-comedy pastiche rather than a message.
  • The film's anti-bullying thread (Trish's death after the Mollys' cruelty sets the killings in motion), which is not tied to identity.
  • Jamie's self-defense training and rape alarm, which stem from her parents' fear of the killer (0:04:48).

Evidence and confidence

Confidence: Medium. Full English SDH subtitles and the forced track for a few Spanish lines. It is not clear what Jamie is reacting to when she remarks on the racism of 1987 (0:23:13) or calls a stranger's shirt problematic (0:21:51).

Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.

Rubric version 3. Reviewed 17 November 2026.