
Woke rating
Lanterns
None or negligible
Average of 8 reviewed episodes
A slow-burning Green Lantern mystery set in small-town Nebraska that keeps identity politics to a few lines, apart from one flashback episode built on John Stewart's parents' conviction that a Black man has to make himself seen.
Lanterns is DC's detective series about two Green Lanterns: Earth's veteran Hal Jordan (Kyle Chandler) and his trainee John Stewart (Aaron Pierre), a former Marine. Drawn to Rushville, Nebraska, after four strangers are shot at a high-school football game, they find a militia rancher with a secret benefactor and a sheriff (Kelly Macdonald) who wants them gone, and the season plays more as a small-town murder mystery than as a superhero show. All eight episodes of the first season were reviewed.
Most of the messaging sits in the third episode, a flashback to John's childhood. His father once failed the ring's one question, 'Are you afraid?', and his mother tells a visiting Guardian that it is unfair to ask a Black man in America that. The parents raise their youngest to be fearless because 'they don't see us', and tell him Hal got the ring only because he was privileged enough never to know fear. Elsewhere it comes a line at a time: a joke about rural views of Obama, a diner chat about rich white men's privilege, a scene about skin colour, John's remark that being a Black man in rural Nebraska is a reason to keep quiet, and his pitch that firepower does not save lives. John's affair with Zoe, the rancher's wife, who is of South Asian appearance, counts lightly in the two episodes where it is a real thread.
Most of the messaging sits in the third episode, a flashback to John's childhood. His father once failed the ring's one question, 'Are you afraid?', and his mother tells a visiting Guardian that it is unfair to ask a Black man in America that. The parents raise their youngest to be fearless because 'they don't see us', and tell him Hal got the ring only because he was privileged enough never to know fear; years later the Guardians recruit John to replace Hal behind his back. Elsewhere it comes a line at a time: a joke about rural views of Obama, a diner chat about rich white men's privilege, a scene about skin colour, John's remark that being a Black man in rural Nebraska is a reason to keep quiet, and his pitch that firepower does not save lives. John's affair with Zoe, the rancher's wife, who is of South Asian appearance and turns out to be the Manhunter, counts lightly in the two episodes where it is a real thread.
What keeps the show near the bottom of the scale is that the messaging seldom reaches beyond that one episode, and even there the Stewarts are no saints: the father drinks and pulls a gun on his wife, and the parents shoot apples off their son's head and lie to him. John is a flawed hero who schemes for his mentor's ring, the villains do not line up with ethnicity, the militia rancher the show jokes about turns out to be right about the aliens, and when the town turns on John it is over damage he and Hal did, which it holds against Hal just as hard. The third episode rates Mild; the other seven come out at 0 or 0.5, which puts the season at 0.5.
What keeps the show near the bottom of the scale is that the messaging seldom reaches beyond that one episode, and even there the Stewarts are no saints: the father drinks and pulls a gun on his wife, and the parents shoot apples off their son's head and lie to him. John is a flawed hero who schemes for his mentor's ring and later walks away from it out of fear, the two Manhunters wear the faces of a South Asian woman and a white teenager, the militia rancher the show jokes about turns out to be right about the aliens, and when the town turns on John it is over damage he and Hal did, which it held against Hal just as hard until he was killed. The third episode rates Mild; the other seven come out at 0 or 0.5, which puts the season at 0.5.
Seasons and episodes
Each reviewed episode is scored on its own. Its categories are scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Open an episode for its breakdown. Timestamps refer to the episode's running time.
Season 1
0.5None or negligible8 episodes reviewed0.0S01E01Little messaging: a buddy-cop set-up in small-town Nebraska, with jokes about a militia rancher and rural views of Obama.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 0 | No race theme, and John is no flawless hero: an impatient trainee who sleeps with a married woman on his first night in town (0:42:22). She is Zoe, of South Asian appearance and married to the white rancher Will Macon, but she is only glimpsed here (0:41:03); both her marriage and the encounter with John are brief, and the partners share an American life, so the mixed-couple steps give 0. |
| B Gender and feminism | 0 | Sheriff Kerry Kane is capable and keeps Hal off her crime scene (0:15:56), but nothing is made of her being a woman. |
| D Power and systems | 0 | Macon likens alien visitors to the settlers who took the Kiowa and Sioux land his ranch is on (0:38:39, 0:39:06), but as a militia rancher's case for arming against aliens, not as a message about Native Americans. |
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | Hal Jordan and John Stewart keep their comics backgrounds: Hal a white test pilot, John a Black man, here a former Marine as in the Justice League cartoons. No actor with a real part plays across sex. |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | The characters with real parts are white, apart from John, whose ethnicity is the comics character's, and Zoe, whose part here is small: at most a single other minority character. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | Hero and rivals alike are mostly white men: Hal, the militia rancher Macon and his lawyer son, and the bar's brawlers. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 1 | Light jabs at rural conservatives: the partners take Macon's ranch for a militia compound by its guns, Hal guesses its owner fears the government will take his guns and rights, and he unmasks the suspect because a real rural Nebraskan would have more to say about Obama. Scored 1: jokes, and Macon dismisses the anti-government guess.
|
C, F, H and I score 0.
Categories add up to 1 of 33, which gives 0.5. Counterweight −0.5: The rancher the episode jokes about gets a fair hearing: he makes his case at dinner (0:38:21 to 0:39:24), rejects the anti-government guess (0:38:04), and his suspicion of the strangers is borne outand the trucker his men suspected turns out to be an alien, as he said (0:47:35). Episode rating 0.0, none or negligible.
0.5S01E02Almost none: a diner conversation in which the rancher's wife jokes about rich white men's privilege.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 1 | In one diner scene Zoe says white men, rich ones above all, have the privilege of being eccentric and doing whatever they want, and John calls her husband a weird white man with a savior complex. Scored 1: one scene of banter. Her marriage and her night with John are only talked about here, and the partners share an American life, so the mixed-couple steps give 0.
|
| D Power and systems | 0 | Macon repeats his comparison with the settlers who colonised the land (0:24:27), again as his case for arming against aliens. |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | As in the first episode: white leads and townsfolk, John, and Zoe in one scene. The alien Antaan and his team are not coded by ethnicity. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | Macon's guard shoots Hal for trespassing (0:25:44), but Hal is white too, and the alien team that seizes John is not coded by ethnicity. Nothing divides along ethnicity or sex. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 0 | Hal teases Macon as a Marlboro Man with an NDA (0:24:56) and Kerry fears he will stir the town into invasion paranoia (0:35:37), but the paranoia is about aliens, not politics. |
B, C, E, F, H and I score 0.
Categories add up to 1 of 33, which gives 0.5. No counterweight: None applies: Zoe brushes off John's jibe by saying she married for love (0:41:24), but nothing in the episode questions her line about white men's privilege. Episode rating 0.5, none or negligible.
2.0S01E03The series' one episode about race: John's parents see the Lantern selection as unfair to Black men and raise their son to make himself seen.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 3 | Race is the episode's spine. John's mother Bernadette tells a visiting Guardian that the ring's question is unfair to a Black man in America, who lives in daily fear of persecution, and that even in space Black people are not considered. She and John's father decide to raise their youngest to be fearless because 'they don't see us', and she tells the boy that Hal got the ring only because he was privileged enough never to know fear, and that sometimes a Black man has to raise his own hand. The parents have real faults (see the counterweight), but nothing in the episode questions this reading of the world.
|
| B Gender and feminism | 0 | Bernadette drives the family's plan and the Guardian calls her formidable (0:10:28), but no point is made about women. |
| D Power and systems | 1 | Two institutions are shown failing Black people in passing: the police doubt that Bernadette's diamond is hers, and in her telling the Guardians' selection overlooks Black men.
|
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | John Stewart is Black in the comics too, and his Marine past follows the Justice League cartoons. His family's backstory is the show's own addition; its race theme is scored under A. |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | The Stewarts are a Black family, as the comics character requires; the Guardian takes the form of a white woman, and Hal and the officers are white. No other mix. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 1 | In this episode Hal is the white man who stands in the way of a Black family: privileged in Bernadette's telling, he costs John his Marine careerwrecks John's last Marine mission on a drunken whim and leaves him to take the blame, then arrives at the Stewarts' table to patronise the parents and threaten John. Scored 1: one character, and the family has faults of its own.
|
| H Didacticism | 2 | Bernadette states the message outright three times, to the Guardian, to her husband and to her son. Scored 2, not 3: they are a mother's speeches, in character, and much of the episode is John's job interview and his training.
|
| I Message over story | 1 | The backstory is staged to make the point: a Guardian calls on Bernadette in the form of a white woman, is told about race in America, admits it did not know and gives its word her son will get a fair shot.
|
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 0 | The military's handling of John's discharge (0:41:15) is a jab at the brass with no party or cause attached. |
C and F score 0.
Categories add up to 8 of 33, which gives 2.5. Counterweight −0.5: The family at the centre is drawn with real faults: John's father drinks and pulls a gun on his wife (0:05:53, 0:06:21), the parents train their youngest by isolating him from his brothers and shooting apples off his head (0:21:25, 0:24:29), Bernadette invents the birds that supposedly report to the Guardians (0:34:43), and the brothers resent John and mock him for talking like a white boy (0:22:06, 0:27:45). Episode rating 2.0, mild.
0.0S01E04Little messaging: a raid on the ranch and John's affair with a married woman, a couple across a colour line.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 1 | John's affair with Zoe is a supporting thread here: she comes to his motel room and they sleep together, and Hal later calls her his girlfriend. John is Black and Zoe of South Asian appearance; they share an American life and differ only in skin colour, so it scores 2 for prominence, minus 1. Her marriage to the white rancher, who says she nursed him through cancer (0:24:18), gets one scene and scores 0 on the same steps. John's outburst that Hal 'didn't do shit to earn' the ring (0:14:16) says nothing about race in this episode.
|
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | A comics villain's name comes up, but the man behind it is not the established characterHector Hammond, a white villain in the comics, is here only a name used by a Latino engineering student acting as a decoy (0:44:34); nothing established is recast. |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | The cast is as before. A Latino character in a small partThe Latino decoy adds nothing under the rubric. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | The bad side is Macon's armed ranch and its hidden benefactor, unmasked at the end as Zoe. Hal plots with Sinestro to disgrace John (0:03:44) while John tells a Guardian the ring has always been his (0:14:28), so neither side lines up with ethnicity or sex. |
B, C, D, F, H, I and J score 0.
Categories add up to 1 of 33, which gives 0.5. Counterweight −0.5: John is shown scheming behind Hal's back for the ring (0:14:07), and the affair is not what it seems.John is shown scheming behind Hal's back for the ring (0:14:07), and the last scene reveals that Zoe, the woman in the episode's mixed couples, is the Manhunter and that her death was faked (0:49:09). Episode rating 0.0, none or negligible.
0.0S01E05Little messaging: one scene of talk about skin colour, given to a character with her own agenda, and an affair across a colour line.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 1 | One scene turns on skinWhile Zoe grows John new skin, the two talk about skin: John jokes the deal is off if he comes out white and says his brothers think life gave him a better shake, and Zoe explains why she chose the face she wears. Their affair is again a supporting thread (2 for prominence, minus 1 for a shared American life). Scored 1: one scene, and the point about prejudice is turned the other way (see the counterweight).
|
| B Gender and feminism | 0 | Kerry's backstory, a young woman on the run from mob killers (0:01:46), is a thriller set-up, not a point about women. |
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 0 | Hal tells Antaan that Macon seduced him (0:21:37), a lie played for laughs; Antaan notes that Hal has always 'presented as heterosexual' (0:21:50). |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | The episode's villain is not whiteThe Manhunter wears the face of Zoe, a woman of South Asian appearance, and Hal, the white lead, plays every side and leaves John in a burning car, so the sides do not divide along ethnicity or sex. |
| H Didacticism | 0 | Zoe's speech on adversity (0:23:44) argues that prejudice makes you stronger, and it is the villain's. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 0 | The town takes up arms to protect its benefactorthe Manhunter (0:08:43), a plot turn with no political framing. |
D, E, F, K and I score 0.
Categories add up to 1 of 33, which gives 0.5. Counterweight −0.5: The one scene about skin argues that prejudice and adversity are a crucible rather than an obstacle (0:24:23), and John answers his brothers' view that life gave him the better shake with 'yes and no' (0:23:30).The one scene about skin is given to the Manhunter, who says she chose a disadvantaged face as a route to power and that prejudice is a crucible rather than an obstacle (0:23:44, 0:24:23); John answers his brothers' view that life gave him the better shake with 'yes and no' (0:23:30), and the woman in the episode's mixed affair is the villain working on him (0:26:47). Episode rating 0.0, none or negligible.
0.0S01E06Two lines: John's pitch that firepower does not save lives, and his remark that being a Black man in rural Nebraska is a reason to keep quiet.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 1 | One exchange: John gives being a Black man in rural Nebraska as his main reason for keeping something from the sheriff, and the waitress who caught him answers that the town is not racist. His brother's teasing about his 'gifted Black ass' (0:43:42) is affection. No mixed couple is shown.
|
| B Gender and feminism | 0 | Hal's jokes about whether a future Lantern could be a womanHal's self-written eulogy, which hedges over whether his successor will be a man or a woman (0:45:39) are at his own expense. |
| D Power and systems | 0 | Kerry jails John for fighting her ex-husband's crew (0:31:10); nothing is framed as racial. |
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | Guy Gardner and Carol Ferris appear as in the comics: a white former gym teacher with a temper (0:32:59) and Hal's old flame (0:43:51). |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | John and his brothers are Black, as the comics character's family would be; Kerry, the townsfolk, Guy Gardner and Carol Ferris are white, and Deputy Lopez has a passing part. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | Billy Macon and his friends jump John over the Lantern signal (0:27:33 to 0:28:16) and a waitress blackmails him (0:39:46), but the town's grudge goes back to the destruction of years ago and fell on Hal as hard as on John: Kerry says everyone hated Hal (0:11:33) and that he went door to door trying to make amends (0:12:40). Kerry, who is white, stands by John. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 1 | John pitches turning a city's federal money for guns into public shelters, on the ground that firepower does not save lives. Scored 1: a business pitch in one scene, and the colonel who controls the money walks out on it (0:49:09).
|
C, F, H and I score 0.
Categories add up to 2 of 33, which gives 0.5. Counterweight −0.5: John's remark about race is answered on the spot (0:39:36), and the episode shows the town's grudge is about the old damage and aimed at Hal as much as at John (0:11:09, 0:12:46); John himself is shown at fault, hiding something from the sheriffhiding that he saw Hal the night he died and having walked away from the ring out of fear, as Hal tells him (0:07:47). Episode rating 0.0, none or negligible.
0.0S01E07No messaging: the investigation leads off-world and into Hal's family history.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 0 | No race theme and no mixed couple: Kerry's love for Hal (0:22:44) is between two white characters. |
| K Diverse cast | 0 | Hal, Kerry, Noah and the townsfolk are white, and John's brothers are heard only on the phone. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | Billy confronts John at his son's school (0:20:09) and the waitress presses her blackmail (0:17:30), over the old disaster, as before. |
B, C, D, E, F, H, I and J score 0.
Categories add up to 0 of 33, which gives 0.0. No counterweight: None applies: nothing in the episode scored, so there is no messaging to complicate. Episode rating 0.0, none or negligible.
0.0S01E08No messaging: the mystery is resolved and John decides what kind of Lantern to be.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 0 | No race theme and no mixed couple. |
| B Gender and feminism | 0 | Kerry stands up for Hal before the town (0:06:00), and the episode turns on her pastand admits she has hidden what her son is, but no point is made about women. |
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | The resolution does not divide along ethnicity or sex: Hal's killer is Noah, a white teenage Manhunter, and his white mother has hidden what he is. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 0 | A young character's fear of his own hunger for powerNoah's fear of his own urge to rise through the military and politics to the levers of power (0:28:12) has no party or cause attached. |
C, D, E, F, K, H and I score 0.
Categories add up to 0 of 33, which gives 0.0. No counterweight: None applies: nothing in the episode scored, so there is no messaging to complicate. Episode rating 0.0, none or negligible.
How the number is reached
- Each reviewed episode is scored A to K and rated like a film: its total out of 33 gives a rating, rounded to the nearest 0.5, less the episode's counterweight. Open an episode above to see how.
- Season 1: the average of 0.0, 0.5, 2.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 and 0.0 gives 0.5.
- With one season reviewed, the show's rating is that season's: 0.5, none or negligible.
Considered, scored 0
- Hal Jordan and John Stewart, the leads, keep their comics backgrounds: a white test pilot and a Black man, here a former Marine as in the Justice League cartoons (E). John is a flawed hero, who schemes for Hal's ring and later turns it down out of fear, not a flawless one (A), and his Black family is the one the character comes with (K).
- Zoe Macon, of South Asian appearance, married to the white rancher Will Macon (S01E01 0:41:03, S01E04 0:24:18): a couple who share an American life, seen only briefly, so 0 on the mixed-couple steps. John's affair with her is likewise brief in S01E01 (0:42:22) and S01E02 (0:39:45); it scores where it becomes a thread, in S01E04 and S01E05 (A).
- Macon's comparison of alien visitors with the settlers who took the Kiowa and Sioux land his ranch is on (S01E01 0:38:39, 0:39:06; S01E02 0:24:27): a militia rancher's case for arming, not a message about Native Americans (D).
- A Latino character in a small part in S01E04Hector Gutierrez, the Latino engineering student behind the name of the comics villain Hector Hammond, who turns out to be a decoy (S01E04 0:44:34), and Deputy Lopez, a passing part (S01E06 0:31:35): Latino characters do not count as non-white (A, E, K).
- Hal's claim to Antaan that Macon seduced him (S01E05 0:21:37), a lie played for laughs (C).
- Hal's jokes about whether a future Lantern could be a womanHal's self-written eulogy, which hedges over whether his successor will be a man or a woman and greets a 'First Lady/Gentleman' (S01E06 0:45:04, 0:45:39), at his own expense (B, C).
- Maggie's demand for 'reparations' for what John and Hal's fight cost her family (S01E06 0:39:46): a claim for damages, not a racial one (A).
- Guy Gardner and Carol Ferris (S01E06 0:32:59, 0:43:51), white as in the comics; Gardner, a gold-toothed former gym teacher, is a figure of fun (E).
- John's veganism, shown up by a slaughterhouse (S01E04 0:40:46) and later dropped (S01E06 0:24:24): a character note, not a message (J).
- No actor with a real part plays across sex (E, K).
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles from the embedded track for all eight episodes of season 1, which are all of the owner's episodes (8 of 8). A few action sequences have little or no dialogue. Zoe's background is not stated in the show; it is judged from the actor, Poorna Jagannathan.
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Noted, not scored: Will Macon, the militia rancher whom Hal takes for a gun-toting paranoid (S01E01 0:34:59, 0:37:53), turns out to be right that the strangers his men shot were aliens (S01E02 0:21:01), and his ranch does hold alien weapons (S01E04 0:19:58). One speech treats prejudice and injustice as a crucible rather than an obstacle (S01E05 0:24:23)The Manhunter's speech that prejudice, injustice and fear are a crucible rather than an obstacle (S01E05 0:24:23), though the speaker has her own agenda; and in the finale John calls blaming one's upbringing 'a cop-out', since anyone who can ask the question can answer it for himself (S01E08 0:26:34).
Rubric version 3. Reviewed 20 November 2026.