
Woke rating
Lioness
Mild
Taylor Sheridan's CIA thriller about women planted beside the families of terrorists is a hawkish war-on-terror procedural; its female-led premise brings some gender messaging, but its politics lean the other way more often than not.
Lioness follows Joe (Zoe Saldaña), the CIA officer who runs a small programme that places female Marines and soldiers undercover beside the wives and daughters of high-value targets, and her boss Kaitlyn Meacham (Nicole Kidman). In season 1 Joe recruits Cruz Manuelos, a young Marine who escaped an abusive boyfriend, to befriend Aaliyah Amrohi, the daughter of a terrorist financier. Season 2 moves to the Mexican border, where an Army helicopter pilot with a cartel uncle is pressed into a hunt for a Chinese agent. Between missions Joe tries, and mostly fails, to be present for her husband Neil and their daughters.
The gender angle supplies most of the points. Cruz beats the men's fitness standard, Joe tells her daughter she wanted to show that a woman can do almost anything, and the season 1 mission dwells on how little say Aaliyah has over her own life: her family chooses her husband and her friends, and Joe predicts a future in a burqa behind compound walls. Cruz's relationship with her mark grows closer than the job allows, and as a match across religion, country and upbringing it counts as a mixed couple, though the show makes that gap part of the story. Joe's marriage to her white husband counts more lightly. Season 2 brings another bond between two women, and the show never comments on either bond being between women. Kaitlyn and a cartel money launderer each get a short indictment of US policy.
The gender angle supplies most of the points. Cruz beats the men's fitness standard, Joe tells her daughter she wanted to show that a woman can do almost anything, and the season 1 mission dwells on how little say Aaliyah has over her own life: her family chooses her husband and her friends, and Joe predicts a future in a burqa behind compound walls. Cruz and Aaliyah become lovers and Cruz tells Joe she is in love; as a match across religion, country and upbringing it counts as a mixed couple, though the show makes that gap the substance of a doomed affair. Joe's marriage to her white husband counts more lightly. Season 2 pairs Cruz with the pilot Josephina, and the show never comments on either couple being two women. Kaitlyn and a cartel money launderer each get a short indictment of US policy.
What keeps the score low is that most of the running time goes to briefings, interagency turf wars and firefights, and the enemies are jihadists, cartel bosses, Iranian troops and Chinese agents rather than any domestic group. The mixed cast is mostly what the US military and government would really have; only the number of gay women among the operators goes beyond that. The show's own politics lean hawkish: it complains about an administration that won't admit there is a border, has a senior officer call climate talk nonsense beside the risk of world war, and tests its characters' love of country. Joe's career is shown at a real cost to her family, and the programme is shown using women as much as empowering them. Only every other episode was reviewed, so the missing half could shift the balance a little.
Score breakdown
Each category is scored 0 to 3: 0 absent or presence only, 1 brief, 2 recurring or plot-relevant, 3 central or dominant. Timestamps refer to the film's running time.
| Category | Score | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Content | ||
| A Ethnicity | 2 | No ethnicity message, but two couples count. Cruz's bond with her mark, Aaliyah, the daughter of a Gulf terrorist financier, is the central relationshipCruz's affair with Aaliyah, the daughter of a Gulf terrorist financier, is the central romance of season 1, so it starts at 3. The two look alike but differ in religion, country and upbringing, and the story does not pass over that gap: her family chooses her husband and her friends, and the bond is shown as one the job and her family cannot allowher family chooses her husband, she calls the wedding a trade, says cancelling it would get her killed and that they have no future, so one point comes off, giving 2. Joe, who is of Dominican descent and visibly darker-skinned, and her white husband Neil are a recurring supporting couple, so 2, but both are Americans of the same upbringing who differ only in skin colour, so one point comes off, giving 1. No non-white character is portrayed as flawless: Joe neglects her family for the job and works on her recruits' weaknesses.
|
| B Gender and feminism | 2 | Women prove themselves against male standards, and Aaliyah's lack of choice in a Gulf family is a running thread of season 1. It recurs and shapes the premise, but it is shown more than argued, and the war plot is the main point.
|
| C Sexuality and gender identity | 0 | No LGBTQ+ message. Cruz grows close to her mark, and season 2 brings another bond between two womenCruz's affair with Aaliyah is a main strand of season 1 and nearly sinks the mission, and season 2 adds a romance between Cruz and Josephina, but the show treats theseboth as an operational problem and a love story, with no comment on sexuality either way, and Cruz is far from flawless: she sleeps with her mark, switches off her transmitter (S01E07 0:24:40) and nearly blows the operation. A lesbian operator's joke about leaving men is barracks banter. The cross-cultural couple is scored under A and the cast's sexuality under K. |
| D Power and systems | 0 | The show is cynical about Washington, but mostly from the operators' side: politicians and rival agencies get in the way of the mission (S02E04 0:31:05). The few lines that indict US policy are not framed as oppression of an identity group and are counted under J. |
| E Cultural and historical revision | 0 | An original series. No established character or history is recast. |
| F Religion portrayal | 0 | Islam itself is not portrayed. The enemies include jihadists and an Iranian-backed militia leader; a suicide bomber starts a takbir as he is shot (S01E05 0:29:25), and a DEA agent scorns jihadists as zealots dreaming of virgins (S02E04 0:09:36). Nothing works as a corrective message. |
| K Diverse cast | 1 | The heroes' side is mixed across ethnicity: Joe is of Dominican descent, Cruz has a Syrian father and a Mexican mother, the team includes the Black operator Tucker, and season 2 has a Black secretary of state and Black officers. That is what a modern US military and government would really have, and the Latino leads do not count as non-white under the rubric. What goes beyond the setting is sexuality: besides Cruz, whose bond with her markwhose affair with her mark is part of the plot, season 2's lead Josephina and another operator are gay women, shown favourably. A few characters of another sexuality in main and supporting parts score 1. No religious mix: the heroes are Christian or unstated.
|
| Treatment | ||
| G Antagonist coding | 0 | The villains are a terrorist financier, Mexican cartels, Iranian forces and a Chinese intelligence network, defined by their crimes. The domestic foils are rival agencies and politicians, driven by turf and budgets, and the heroes' side is full of white men too (the team's operators, Byron Westfield), so the moral sides do not divide along ethnicity or sex. The men who prey on Cruz are individuals, not a coded group. |
| H Didacticism | 1 | Few speeches state a progressive message: the clearest is Joe's line to her daughter about what a woman can do. Kaitlyn's short lecture on US policy in the Gulf is general politics, counted under J, and the show's longer speeches are about duty, patriotism and the cost of war.
|
| I Message over story | 0 | The story leads. The female-led premise has a practical reason given on screen (only women can get close to the targets' wives and daughters, S01E01 0:28:58), the plot turns follow mission logic, and neither the couples nor the cast mix bend the story. |
| J Left-leaning politics framed as good | 1 | Two brief indictments of US policy: Kaitlyn's short lecture on how Washington props up the Gulf states' rulers, and a cartel money launderer's claim that the CIA brought heroin back to America. Otherwise the show's politics lean the other way, on borders, climate and patriotism (see notScored).
|
How the number is reached
- Categories A to K add up to 7 of 33, which gives 2.0 (7 ÷ 33 × 10, rounded to the nearest 0.5).
- Counterweight −0.5: the show complicates its own female-power framing. Joe's career is shown costing her family: she tells Kate she knows her daughter thinks she is a bad mother and that Kate pays for the job she chose (S01E05 0:07:28, 0:07:49), urges her to stay a girl as long as she can (S01E05 0:09:30), and decides to ask for a desk job after leaving her injured daughter (S01E07 0:37:11). The programme itself uses women: Joe works on Cruz's loneliness and history of abuse to keep her undercover (S01E07 0:20:02), and a recruit tells Joe she has never met a woman who came out of the programme (S02E02 0:44:12).
- Final rating 1.5, mild.
Considered, scored 0
- Cruz's close bond with Aaliyah (S01E07 0:09:26)Cruz's affair with Aaliyah, with a sex scene (S01E07 0:10:52, 0:13:30), the team overhearing them (0:15:28) and Cruz's confession to Joe that she is in love (0:19:14): no comment on its being between two women, and Cruz is not flawless (C); it is scored as a couple across cultures under A.
- A second bond between two women in season 2 (S02E06 0:14:02)Cruz and Josephina's romance in season 2: her father asks whether Cruz is her girlfriend (S02E06 0:14:02), they make a date (S02E08 0:08:30) and one tells the other she loves her during a last stand (S02E08 0:41:47): two American women of Latin American descent, so not a mixed couple, and shown without comment (A, C).
- A lesbian operator's joke that she abandoned the side with a penis, and the teasing that follows (S02E02 0:18:48, 0:19:57): barracks banter, not a message (C); she counts towards the cast mix under K.
- Black commanders and operators and a Black cabinet official in the White House meetings (S02E06 0:34:30), and a lead whose father is Syrian and mother Mexican (S01E01 0:27:00): the mix a modern US military and government would have (K).
- Josephina's Mexican-American family and her parents' choice to raise her speaking only English (S02E02 0:41:49), plain background.
- Cruz's escape from an abusive boyfriend and the Marine who steps in (S01E01 0:12:19, 0:12:57): her back-story.
- Joe's line that an Israeli concertgoer or a child in Gaza can show the cost of surrender (S02E04 0:23:18), a point about war that names both sides.
Evidence and confidence
Confidence: Medium. Full English subtitles (the embedded English track). 8 of the owner's 16 episodes were reviewed, every other one across seasons 1 and 2 (S01E01, S01E03, S01E05, S01E07, S02E02, S02E04, S02E06, S02E08); the season 1 finale was not among them. A few short Spanish exchanges are left in Spanish in the subtitles (S02E06 0:20:36, S02E08 0:27:03) and were translated while reading.
Category F definition: As in the rubric: Islam shown as a peaceful and tolerant religion, aligned with human rights, in a way that works as a corrective message.
Noted, not scored: The show's own politics often lean hawkish or conservative: a CIA officer complains that the administration won't even admit there is a border (S01E03 0:37:37); a senior official ties the finale's mission to America's open bordera senior official says the strike into Iran is payback for America's open border (S02E08 0:19:06); Kaitlyn calls climate change nonsense beside the risk of world war, while wanting energy from anything but oil for security's sake (S01E07 0:40:39); Joe presses Josephina to say she loves her country (S02E02 0:42:39) and explains her own service through her immigrant grandfather, who enlisted after Pearl Harbor (S02E02 0:10:12); and a teenager calls her father 'based' for scorning almond milk (S02E06 0:07:56). When Kate asks whether her mother ever had an abortion, Joe answers that Kate would not exist if she had (S01E05 0:11:26), and she calls Kate's miscarriage God's decision (S01E05 0:10:02).
Episodes reviewed: S01E01, S01E03, S01E05, S01E07, S02E02, S02E04, S02E06, S02E08.
Rubric version 3. Reviewed 18 November 2026.